BOPIS Policies: Hold Times, ID Rules & Returns (Retail Examples)

Photo by fauxels on Pexels

You've set up BOPIS, but your policies are vague or missing entirely. Customers ask "how long will you hold my order?" and staff shrug. Someone's friend tries to pick up their order and you're not sure if that's allowed. A customer wants to return something at pickup and nobody knows the rule.

Clear policies prevent these daily headaches. They also protect you legally and operationally—you need documented rules for hold times, identification, returns, and fees before disputes arise.

This guide shows you exactly what Target, Walmart, and Best Buy do—their actual published policies on hold times, ID requirements, proxy pickups, returns, and cancellations. Then we'll give you copy-ready templates you can customize for your store. By the end, you'll have complete pickup policies you can publish on your website, print for staff, and reference when customers ask questions.

Why Clear Policies Matter (Legal & Operational)

Policies aren't just legal protection—they're operational necessities. Every unclear policy creates staff confusion and customer frustration.

Legal Protection

Published policies establish the terms of your pickup service. If a customer claims you should have held their order for two weeks, your published 3-day policy proves otherwise. If someone disputes a no-show cancellation, your policy shows they agreed to pickup within X days.

Without documented policies, disputes become he-said-she-said arguments where you have no written proof. Courts and payment processors favor written policies over verbal claims.

Operational Consistency

Staff need clear rules for daily decisions. "Can this person pick up someone else's order?" becomes a yes/no decision based on policy, not a judgment call that varies by employee.

Consistent policies also prevent favoritism accusations. If you hold one customer's order for 10 days but cancel another's after 4 days, the second customer feels unfairly treated. Policy-driven decisions eliminate this.

Customer Expectations

Customers who know the rules upfront don't argue later. If your confirmation email says "orders held 3 days," customers pick up within 3 days. If it's silent on hold times, customers assume you'll hold it indefinitely and get angry when you cancel on day 5.

Clear communication of policies also builds trust. Major retailers succeed partly because their policies are transparent, consistent, and easy to find.

Where to Publish Your Policies

Customers should see policies in three places:

• Website FAQ or pickup page — Detailed policy document customers can reference
• Checkout flow — Brief summary during order placement
• Order confirmation email — Key policies (hold time, ID required) repeated

Staff need policies in two places:

• Training materials — Complete policy explanations with examples
• Quick reference card — One-page cheat sheet at the pickup counter

Now let's look at what the major retailers actually do, category by category.

Hold Times: How Long to Keep Orders

Hold time is how long you'll store a ready order before canceling and refunding it. This is the most important policy to establish—it impacts inventory, storage space, and customer behavior.

Target's Hold Time Policy

According to Target's pickup policies, they hold Drive Up orders for 3 days from when the order is marked ready.

Key details:

• 3-day hold starts when you receive "ready for pickup" notification, not when you place the order
• Reminders sent at 24 hours and 48 hours after ready
• After 3 days, order automatically cancels and refunds
• Perishable items (groceries, food) may have shorter holds—often same-day or next-day only

Target's reasoning: 3 days balances customer convenience with operational efficiency. Most customers pick up within 24 hours; 3 days catches busy customers without tying up inventory too long.

Best Buy's Hold Time Policy

Best Buy holds pickup orders for 5 days from the ready notification.

Key details:

• 5-day hold for most products
• Large items (TVs, appliances) may have shorter holds due to storage constraints
• Major releases (new iPhone, gaming consoles) may have 24-48 hour holds only
• After 5 days, order cancels and refunds automatically
• You can request extension by calling the store before expiration

Best Buy's reasoning: 5 days accommodates business travelers and busy professionals who can't always pick up immediately. Longer hold builds customer loyalty.

Walmart's Hold Time Policy

Walmart's policy varies by product category:

• General merchandise: 7 days hold
• Groceries and perishables: Must pick up by end of next business day after ready notification (effectively 24-48 hours)
• Pharmacy items: Follow pharmacy-specific regulations (varies by state)
• Auto-cancel and refund after hold period expires

Walmart's reasoning: Different products have different storage needs. Non-perishables can sit for a week; groceries spoil. Product-specific holds optimize storage and minimize waste.

Industry Standard Hold Times

Based on these examples and broader retail analysis:

Recommended Policy Language

Here's copy-ready hold time language you can customize:

Customize the bracketed sections for your store's capacity and product type.

ID Requirements & Verification

Should you require photo ID? What if the name doesn't match? These policies prevent fraud while staying customer-friendly.

Target's ID Policy

Target's Drive Up doesn't strictly require photo ID for most orders. Instead, they verify via:

• Order barcode in the Target app (primary verification)
• Customer provides order number when they arrive
• Staff matches order to customer's phone number or name
• Photo ID required for alcohol, tobacco, or high-value orders ($500+)

Target's reasoning: App-based verification is faster and more convenient than ID checks. Reserve ID for regulated products and fraud prevention on expensive items.

Best Buy's ID Policy

Best Buy requires photo ID for in-store pickup, with specific rules:

• Photo ID must match the name on the order
• Accepted IDs: driver's license, state ID, passport, military ID
• For high-value electronics ($500+), ID is strictly enforced
• Staff may ask security questions (billing address, last 4 of card) as additional verification

Best Buy's reasoning: Electronics have high resale value and theft risk. Strict ID verification prevents fraud and credit card chargebacks.

Walmart's ID Policy

Walmart's policy is app-first with ID as backup:

• Preferred: verification code sent to customer's phone (via Walmart app or SMS)
• Backup: photo ID matching order name
• Mandatory ID for restricted items (alcohol, firearms, pharmacy)
• General merchandise under $50: often no ID check, just order number

Walmart's reasoning: Balance security with speed. Verification codes are faster than ID checks; save ID requirement for high-risk items.

Recommended ID Policy

Most stores should use a tiered approach:

Low-value orders (under $100): Order number + confirmation email sufficient. Optional ID check if staff suspects fraud.

Mid-value orders ($100-500): Require one of: photo ID matching name, confirmation email + security question (billing ZIP, phone number), or app verification code.

High-value orders ($500+): Photo ID matching order name required, no exceptions.

Regulated products (alcohol, tobacco, pharmacy): Photo ID required by law, must verify age/prescription.

Edge Case: Name Doesn't Match ID

What if the customer's credit card name differs from their ID (married name change, legal name vs nickname)?

Flexible solution: Accept ID if it matches the pickup person's name, even if slightly different from order name, as long as they can provide order number and answer security questions. Document variations in your POS notes ("Jane Smith order, picked up by Jane Jones - verified via order # and phone").

For complete BOPIS setup including operational workflows, see our Holiday Playbook.

Proxy Pickup (Someone Else Picks Up)

Can the customer's spouse, friend, or assistant pick up their order? Proxy pickup policies balance convenience with fraud prevention.

Target's Proxy Pickup Policy

Target allows proxy pickup with minimal verification:

• Anyone with the order barcode (in the Target app) can pick up
• Purchaser can share the barcode via screenshot or "add to wallet" feature
• No ID required unless it's a restricted item
• Proxy picker doesn't need to match order name

Target's reasoning: Customers value flexibility. If the purchaser trusts someone enough to share the order barcode, Target trusts that relationship. Barcode acts as the authorization token.

Best Buy's Proxy Pickup Policy

Best Buy is stricter on proxy pickup:

• Default: only person whose name is on the order can pick up
• Exception: purchaser can call store in advance to authorize alternate pickup person by name
• Alternate picker must provide their own photo ID
• Store notes the authorization in the order system
• For very high-value items, may require written authorization

Best Buy's reasoning: Electronics theft risk requires stricter controls. Authorization process creates an audit trail if disputes arise.

Walmart's Proxy Pickup Policy

Walmart takes a middle-ground approach:

• Anyone with the pickup confirmation email/text can collect the order
• Or purchaser can add alternate pickup person in the Walmart app
• Alternate person provides their own ID (doesn't need to match order name)
• For restricted items, purchaser must be present (alcohol, pharmacy)

Walmart's reasoning: Email confirmation serves as implicit authorization. If the purchaser forwarded it, they've authorized that person.

Recommended Proxy Pickup Policy

Choose based on your fraud risk tolerance:

Lenient (low fraud risk, convenience-focused): Anyone with order number and confirmation email can pick up. No ID required unless order value exceeds threshold or restricted items.

Moderate (balanced): Proxy pickup allowed if alternate person has confirmation email and can provide their own photo ID. Order name doesn't need to match.

Strict (high fraud risk, valuable items): Only person on order can pick up unless purchaser calls/emails in advance to authorize specific alternate by name. Alternate must show their ID.

Documenting Proxy Pickups

When someone other than the purchaser picks up, staff should note it in your POS or order system:

"Order #1234 (Jane Smith) picked up by John Doe, ID verified [driver's license #XXXX], had confirmation email, [date/time]."

This documentation protects you if the purchaser later claims they never received the order.

Returns & Exchanges at Pickup

Can customers return or exchange items when they pick up their order? What about items from previous orders?

Target's Return at Pickup Policy

Target allows returns during Drive Up with limitations:

• You can return items from previous orders during your pickup visit
• Returns must be processed inside at customer service (not curbside)
• You can't return items from the order you're currently picking up until after you've accepted it
• Standard return policy applies (receipt required, within return window)

Target's reasoning: Accept returns at pickup for convenience but process inside to maintain pickup speed. Can't return items you haven't technically received yet.

Best Buy's Return at Pickup Policy

Best Buy processes returns at the same counter as pickup:

• Pickup counter handles both pickup and returns
• You can return items from previous orders when picking up new orders
• Can't return items from current pickup order until you've received and inspected them
• Return window and receipt requirements follow standard Best Buy return policy

Best Buy's reasoning: Combined counter streamlines operations. Customers save a trip by handling returns during pickup.

Walmart's Return at Pickup Policy

Walmart separates pickup and returns:

• Pickup orders are handed off curbside or at pickup counter
• Returns must be processed at customer service desk (separate location)
• You can do both in one visit, but they're separate transactions
• Can't return unopened items from current pickup before taking possession

Walmart's reasoning: Separation keeps pickup line moving fast. Returns require more processing time; dedicated counter handles that complexity.

Recommended Return at Pickup Policy

Your policy should address three scenarios:

Scenario 1: Return from previous order
Decision: Allow it, but process at customer service (not pickup counter) to maintain pickup speed.
Policy: "You can return items from previous orders during your pickup visit. Please bring returns inside to customer service—our pickup team focuses on getting your new order to you quickly."

Scenario 2: Exchange item in current pickup order
Decision: Allow if replacement is in stock and customer hasn't left the parking lot yet.
Policy: "If you notice an issue with your pickup order before leaving the parking area, we can exchange it for the correct item if in stock. Once you leave, standard return policy applies."

Scenario 3: Return entire current pickup order
Decision: Allow refusal of order before handoff completes.
Policy: "You can refuse your pickup order before we complete the handoff if you've changed your mind. Once accepted, our standard return window applies."

Damaged or Incorrect Items at Pickup

Special case: customer discovers damage or wrong item during pickup. Fast resolution keeps customers happy:

Immediate resolution policy: "If your pickup order is damaged or incorrect, notify our staff before leaving the pickup area. We'll replace the item immediately if in stock, or process a full refund on the spot. Once you leave the area, our standard return process applies."

This puts the burden on customers to inspect before leaving, but gives them a fast fix if they do.

Fees, Minimums & Payment Policies

Is pickup free? Do you require a minimum order? When do customers pay?

Major Retailer Fee Policies

Target: Free pickup, no minimum order value. Drive Up is completely free for all order sizes.

Best Buy: Free pickup, no minimum. Positioned as a perk to compete with Amazon.

Walmart: Free pickup, but minimum order value for grocery pickup ($35 minimum). General merchandise has no minimum.

Industry standard: Free pickup with no minimum is the expectation customers have. Charging fees or requiring minimums reduces adoption.

Should You Charge for Pickup?

Short answer: no. Pickup costs you $2-4 in labor and materials per order—far less than shipping or the customer acquisition cost of not offering pickup.

Free pickup also drives foot traffic. Customers picking up orders often browse and buy additional items in-store. That incremental revenue offsets pickup costs.

Exception: If you want to control volume without adding staff, you could use fees strategically: "Free pickup for orders over $50; $3 service fee for orders under $50." This naturally prioritizes higher-value orders. But most stores should avoid fees entirely.

Payment Timing

All three major retailers require payment at checkout (when ordering online), not at pickup. This is standard for BOPIS:

Why payment at checkout:

• Prevents no-shows (customer already paid, more likely to pick up)
• Faster handoff (no payment transaction at pickup)
• Reduces fraud (card is authorized before you pull inventory)
• Guarantees the sale (customer can't change mind at pickup and walk away)

Exception: Some restaurants and food services allow "order ahead, pay at pickup" because food is perishable and they want to minimize no-shows' impact on waste. But for retail goods, prepayment is standard.

Minimum Order Value Decision

If you're considering a minimum, weigh these factors:

Recommendation: Start with no minimum. Add a minimum only if volume becomes unmanageable and you can't add staff.

Cancellations & Refunds

When can customers cancel? What if they don't pick up? How fast do refunds process?

Customer-Initiated Cancellations

Target: Customers can cancel pickup orders anytime before marking the order as "on my way" in the app. Once marked "on my way," cancellation requires calling the store.

Best Buy: Cancel online through your account or by calling the store anytime before pickup. If order is already being prepared, cancellation may take 24 hours to process.

Walmart: Cancel online through your account up until the order is marked "ready for pickup." After that, contact the store by phone to cancel.

Common pattern: Easy cancellation until order is ready or customer is en route. After that point, contact store directly because inventory has been pulled and staged.

Store-Initiated Cancellations

You cancel orders in three scenarios:

1. Hold time expired (no-show): After your hold period (3-7 days), auto-cancel and refund. Send notification: "Your pickup order #X expired after [X] days and has been canceled. Your payment has been refunded. We hope to serve you again soon."

2. Out of stock after order placed: If you discover item is unavailable, contact customer immediately with options: wait for restock, partial fulfillment with refund, or full cancellation. Don't just cancel without communication.

3. Suspected fraud: If payment is declined on verification or order seems fraudulent, cancel and note reason in system. Contact only if you need additional verification to approve it.

Refund Processing Time

All three major retailers process refunds within 3-7 business days, depending on the customer's bank.

Target: Refund issued within 24 hours; appears in customer's account in 3-5 business days.

Best Buy: Refund processed when order cancels; customer sees it in 5-7 business days.

Walmart: Immediate refund initiation; 3-5 days to appear in account.

Set expectations clearly: "Refunds are processed within 24 hours and typically appear in your account within 3-5 business days, depending on your bank."

Partial Pickups & Partial Refunds

What if an order has 5 items but only 4 are available? Policy options:

Option A (automatic partial fulfillment): "If items in your order are unavailable, we'll fulfill what we can and refund the unavailable items. You'll receive an email notification before pickup."

Option B (contact customer first): "If items are unavailable, we'll contact you at [phone/email] to ask if you want partial fulfillment or full cancellation."

Option B is more customer-friendly but requires staff time. Option A is operationally simpler but risks customer frustration if the unavailable item was critical.

Compromise: Use Option A for low-value items (under $20), Option B for high-value items or when unavailable item represents >50% of order value.

Copy-Ready Policy Templates

Here's a complete policy document you can customize and publish on your website.

Copy this template into a Word doc, fill in the bracketed sections with your specific details, and publish it on your website under "Pickup FAQ" or "Store Pickup Policy."

For complete BOPIS implementation including Shopify setup, see our Shopify setup guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Continue Your BOPIS Implementation

Policies are one piece of your complete pickup program. For the full operational picture:

• BOPIS & Curbside Holiday Playbook 2025 — Complete operational guide with setup, signage, staffing, and SLA calculators
• Shopify BOPIS Setup Guide — Step-by-step Shopify configuration with screenshots and testing protocols
• Free Curbside Pickup Signage Templates — Print-ready signs for stalls, A-frames, and directional markers
• BOPIS Best Practices for Holiday 2025 — Peak season tactics, queue management, and staffing models
• Same-Day Pickup Store Finder — Searchable directory of retailers with pickup policies

Have questions about setting pickup policies for your specific situation? Drop a comment below or share this guide with other retailers navigating BOPIS policies.